Rational Expectations of Own Performance: An Experimental Study
نویسندگان
چکیده
_____________________________________________________________________ According to rational choice theory, people will choose their careers, level of work effort or investment based in part on their expectations of success. But are people’s expectations of their likelihood of success accurate? Evidence accumulated by psychologists suggest that on average people underestimate their risks and overestimate their abilities relative to others. We test for such optimistic bias in experiments where people must predict their relative or absolute success in incentivebased verbal and maximization contests. We ask subjects to provide initial and revised point estimates of their success rates, either hypothetically or with a scoring rule that rewards forecast accuracy. We then passively measure the quantity and quality of subjects’ efforts and subsequent outcomes. Bias in forecasts is evaluated at the aggregate level as done by psychologists, but also at the individual level using realized outcomes. We find limited evidence of excess optimism only in relative maximization contests when encountered first, and excess pessimism or accuracy elsewhere. Experience across contests and updating does not always increase the accuracy of self-assessed forecasts, and even when accuracy improves biases are rarely eliminated entirely. Methodologically, we find no evidence that a modest quadratic scoring rule introduces moral hazard for own-outcome forecasts, but neither does it increase forecast accuracy or lower variance. _____________________________________________________________________ * Department of Economics, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch, New Zealand. [email protected] Phone: 011 643 364-2308 Fax: 011 643 364-2635 † Commerce Division, Lincoln University, PO Box 84, Canterbury, New Zealand [email protected] Phone: 011 643 325-3627 Fax: 011 643 325-3847
منابع مشابه
Testing for Stochastic Non- Linearity in the Rational Expectations Permanent Income Hypothesis
The Rational Expectations Permanent Income Hypothesis implies that consumption follows a martingale. However, most empirical tests have rejected the hypothesis. Those empirical tests are based on linear models. If the data generating process is non-linear, conventional tests may not assess some of the randomness properly. As a result, inference based on conventional tests of linear models can b...
متن کاملThe Impact of Rational Governance on the Financial Performance of Industrial Companies Sample (Pharmaceutical Companies) Listed in Amman Stock Exchange
The study aimed to determine the impact between rational governance and financial performance on a sample of pharmaceutical companies listed in the Amman Stock Exchange. The questionnaire was used to collect data, where (200) inquiries were received (170) valid for statistical analysis were excluded (10) where used in Analysis process (160) of the total questionnaires distributed and to achieve...
متن کاملA Simple Test of Rational Expectations
Do We Follow Others When We Should? A Simple Test of Rational Expectations The paper presents a new meta data set covering 13 experiments on the social learning games by Bikhchandani, Hirshleifer, and Welch (1992). The large amount of data makes it possible to estimate the empirically optimal action for a large variety of decision situations and ask about the economic significance of suboptimal...
متن کاملThe Effect of Intervention Based on Dweck’s Mind Set on Academic Expectations Stress in Gifted and Talented School Students
It is very stressful to constantly struggle to meet the expectations of others or expectations of self, and it affects onechr(chr('39')39chr('39'))s performance. The purpose of this study was the effect of intervention based on Dweck’s mind set on academic expectations stress in gifted and talented school students. The project’s plan was a quasi-experimental study with a pretest-posttest des...
متن کاملStabilisation policy, rational expectations and price-level versus ination targeting: a survey
We survey literature comparing ination targeting (IT) and price-level targeting (PT) as macroeconomic stabilisation policies. Our focus is on New Keynesian models and areas that have seen signi cant developments since Amblers (2009) survey: optimal monetary policy; the zero lower bound; nancial frictions; and transition costs of adopting a PT regime. Amblers conclusion that PT improves soci...
متن کامل